A number of my posts, particularly the ones dealing with transgender issues in my life, have been written on a long, dark night of the soul. It can be difficult to come back and read what I’ve posted and resist the urge to delete what I’ve written, because of how dark they are. I have moments when I think, if ever a family member happened to read them, some of what I’ve written could really hurt them. That was never the intention, and yet, there is a ring of truth to the posts I am not able to deny. It is an unfortunate fact that I’ve been hurt a great deal by people who never meant me harm because of things neither I nor they had any control over. It is not their fault that efforts to encourage my growth and development as a son or brother caused me so much pain; they were simply responding to what they perceived me to be. Our current society is the end product of thousands of generations of people struggling through life trying to make sense out of it. If that resulted in the division of human traits into masculine and feminine, and if the cultivation of gender roles led to a society that could not understand that there was a difference between the things that make people who they are and the things that make them what they are, it is not possible to assign fault or blame to any specific group, let alone a given person. As much as it would have made a difference in my life to have been raised among people who were more perceptive, or in a society that was more accepting of individual differences, I would still have grown up with the more difficult problem of being a girl in a boy’s body.

I can look back now and say it would have been better if I had been more assertive, but like most people I did not come into the world with all the answers and because I understood the reality of my situation, I tried to adjust to it. It took a long time to prove to myself that I was right from the beginning to think of myself as a girl. I had to destroy myself trying to be a boy and a man to understand that the only way I could survive as a person was by being true to myself. That was hard, and it is still hard, because there is nothing I hate more than the idea of being a woman trapped in a man’s body. How can I possibly be true to myself when I am betrayed by my own flesh? What future is there for a living contradiction like this? So, even when I am tempted to regret allowing myself to be forced into a role I cannot endure, I can understand how I could try to hard to be what everyone else expected me to be. I tried to be the person everyone thought me to be in the hope that, if I could not hope to live for myself, I could at least live for the people I cared about — the people who cared for me. I had no idea it would cost me so much, or that in the end I would be driven into isolation and have to face the simple, horrible truth of my existence. I lived a lie, and that is why I do not feel deserving of the love my family and friends have had for me. I hate the person I tried to be, and in that irrational way of such emotions, I hate everyone who ever loved that person. I’ve never been the type to hold on to negative emotions; I know that they arise in response to things I perceive to be wrong, cruel and unfair. I could never point a finger of blame, because I keep analyzing the problem until I understand it and what I did, or did not do, to bring it about.

I am a girl in a male body because I found myself and believed in myself, and it ended up hurting me because I allowed the circumstances I was in to overwhelm me. I knew the truth and allowed myself to doubt it. That doubt was all the leverage needed to turn my life into hell. I tried to deny the truth and struggled to believe the lie I created to survive in the world of doubt I had embraced. Why? Do the facts really matter if they contradict the truth? Is reality worth holding onto if you have to dispose of yourself in the process? I could never silence these questions, and part of me struggled to hold onto the one truth I had. I know there have been times when I wondered why this was happening to me, and there are answers I could give myself, but in a lot of ways it was not the question that mattered. If I tried to look at my life as a story, then everything that happens is just part of the plot, and if I think of myself as the protagonist of the story, then it’s all a puzzle I have to figure out. Even if I just call it a life, then the challenge of every experience is to find meaning in what is happening to me. When I open my eyes and consider what is happening with everyone all over the world, then it begins to look like a proving ground, and the purpose of everything that happens in life is to find out what it takes to destroy us. When I think about it, though, I feel like I’ve survived too many things that should have destroyed me, often in ways I would have preferred not to have survived. Even worse, it often seems that it has been because of my weaknesses, not my strengths, that I have been able to survive. I mean, if a person can really die of a broken heart, I could have died a thousand times a day.

The hardest thing to endure is the idea that this is a world without magic and miracles, a world where it is not possible to transform this body of mine in a way that would make it mine. I cling to my sanity in the face of a reality in which the very thing that supports my existence is the thing that denies me the ability to truly live. I’ve always known that there are others who have experienced a conflict between who they are and what they appear to be. I also know that appearances matter no matter what anyone says to the contrary. It is not necessary to be gender dysphoric to feel betrayed by one’s body. It is enough to simply look different. In many ways, it is easier to accept what other people look like than to accept our own appearance. I always had a hard time with the fact that I appeared perfectly normal to other people but felt horribly deformed, with parts of me literally turned inside out. I feel the distortion of my body image by my physical senses as a constant dislocation and disorientation, like I have two bodies, a male body overlapping a female body — which is a lot like wearing over-sized boots all over. That should go a long way towards explaining my instinctive understanding of four-dimensional space, as well as my intuitions about the nature of the mind, soul and spirit. Even as a child, I found it easy to comprehend magic and miracles in terms of multi-dimensional functions, though even now it’s difficult to describe what is clear in my mind using words. Of course, what I think of and associate with the terms “magic” and “miracle” are a bit different from what I find in most literature. For a while, I thought it might be more appropriate to use the term “psychic” or “psionic” instead, but even those terms are met with suspicion and skepticism these days, and I can understand why.

I recall pointing out somewhere that magic is the ability to change reality in spite of what you believe, while a miracle is a change in reality based on belief, and that both are expressions of psychic potential. These were clarifications I made to distinguish the concepts for my own use, both in fiction and in philosophy. As far as I am concerned, there should be no stigma attached to these words, or any mystery or occult terms passed down into the English language, even if scientists and skeptics do like to view them with contempt. Concepts are necessary to communicate ideas, and even if there is no scientific basis for their use, they provide a rich vocabulary for expressing ideas that are otherwise hard to articulate. It’s an approach I’ve been using all along, in previous posts. It was inevitable what I would reach a point where I would feel the need to comment on my use of such terms, just as it is inevitable for a child born in the wrong body to wish for metamorphosis. If all I had done was wish for change, I would have lost it a long time ago. The part of growing up and outgrowing fairy tales and children’s fantasy would have left me hopeless. So, I had to put more effort into searching for a way to change, which meant doing my own research into miracles, magic and medicine. Since I did not have money to throw into it, I was pretty much limited to what could be found in libraries and book stores or what could be learned from other people. It is not hard to find people with strong beliefs about magic or religion, and medical practices are pretty well documented; it did not take long to conclude that what I was looking for was beyond the reach of medicine, and what most people who believed in magic or divine intervention would consider possible.

I should say, anyone who believes in God would say He has the power to transform a body, but since He is our Creator we are meant to be the way He made us. To believe otherwise is perceived as a sign of demonic or satanic influence. I have had this kind of theology used against me, and it falls apart with just a little analysis. We could not be vulnerable to demonic or satanic influence upon our identities unless we had the capacity to redefine ourselves, and we would only have the capacity to redefine ourselves if we were meant to assert our own identities. God might determine where we start out in life, but I don’t think we would be able to live without free will; if it’s all God’s will, then there’s really no one here but God playing with meat puppets. If we are free to make our own choices, who we are is a reflection of those choices, even if we cannot act on them. The problem most of us face in life is not having the opportunities to make the choices we really want to. One of the ways you find out who you are is by understanding the path you choose to take, and why. In any case, the world we live in only makes sense if we have true free will; there is clearly nothing limiting the choices people have except the consequences of those we act on. By chance or design, we are free to do anything we take it upon ourselves to do, and it’s up to us to figure out what the right thing to do is and to do the right thing because it is what we choose to do. In the end, we become better people by choosing to be our best, without the need for threats or coercion.

For all I know, the point of my life was to come to this understanding, to live a lie long enough to want nothing more than to be true to myself and find a way to be true to others, to understand how vital it is to be true even if the truth is out of reach. Perhaps that is something that can only be understood when you need something you cannot have, when you aspire for something that cannot be obtained with words, or actions. The thing I have sought my entire life is the power to change myself, not because I want power for its own sake, but because I need that power to become the person I want to be, the best person I can be. I can be honest and say I am not happy to be the best I can be; it’s not enough to make the most out of what I’ve been given. I want to be the best I can dream of being, and I wish I could achieve that on my own, without compromise. I’m not sure if that is possible in this world. I believe in the possibility, but what I believe only affects what I can accept as possible. In all probability, I will die for that belief because I don’t want to live in a world where it will not come true. Until then, however, I will keep thinking about what it would take to change the world just enough to make myself truly part of it.

10 responses to “Point Penetrating Points Overlapping”

  1. Before, you are girl or boy, deeper than you are male or female, you are man, that is to say human.

    1. If your point is that the human potential or the potential of the soul of every person encompasses both male and female, I have to agree. However, when speaking of who I am as a person, I am generally referring to the human condition of being one or the other, and assuming one cannot change back and forth, knowing which one best embodies who I am. The traits and characteristics that I possess, the way I think and feel, the way I act and react, and the perspective that is most natural for me, is female. More of who and what I am can be encompassed and expressed through a female form. When expressed through a male form, there is too much distortion and discomfort — like Chinese water torture, any given drop is endurable, but taken as a whole and without reprieve, the experience is agonizing.

      1. I suppose I find it strange, that people so deeply identify with a gender (the one they have or the one they don’t). It is something I have never really experienced. There is so much to be experienced in life that getting hung up on sexuality seems odd to me. When you read a book, or watch a sunset, or listen to someone, or give a gift, or climb a hill, or draw a scene, or calculate a calculation… does gender come into it at all? Is it significant that the one doing the thing is male or female?

        If it is… I admit, I find that very hard to grasp.

      2. That is an interesting comment, considering the fact that on your own blog, on your “Moi” page, the first words are “I am a girl.” When I was five years old, a group of boys tried to drown me for saying those same words when they tried to mock me for playing with a girl. Gender, which is distinct from sex, sexuality and sexual orientation, is a key part of identity and when there is a profound difference between how you see your self and how other people see you, it becomes a serious problem. If you are really curious, try reading some of my other transgender posts; I’ve already written a lot about this, too much to repeat here.

      3. But “I am a girl” is just a game.

        When I conform to gender roles, I feel like I am playing a game. It is a fun game, but its not reality.

        When life feels real these things don’t matter.

      4. Perhaps saying that being a girl is just a game to you is a way of asserting that you do not allow yourself to be defined by your circumstances. It can also mean that you are so comfortable with what you are that it does not even occur to you to question it. Only you know for sure. When I was a kid, “You are a boy” was just a game to me, a game that everyone around me took much more seriously than I did. As time went on and people put more effort into forcing me to play along, it stopped being fun. When it got to the point where I could not be myself without fear of reprisal, it ceased to be a game and became a matter of survival. You would know that if you had read some of my other posts. But again, I do not blame people for not understanding and the only question I have for you — since you first pointed out that you did not understand why this issue affects some people — is, do you actually want to understand?

        Interestingly enough, I do not find it hard to understand you when you say “When I conform to gender roles, I feel like I am playing a game.” I’ve often used the game metaphor to describe and even deal with things in life, most often to point out that even a child can tell if the rules of a game are not fair or to say that there is no point to playing the game you have to cheat at in order to win. I’ve often said that we’re all like a bunch of kids making up the rules of the game as we go along, and there is a lot of truth in that. Most of all, when I talk about people who treat life like a game, I mean that it allows them to ignore the consequences of their thoughts and actions. It is not a bad thing, in itself, it just means that its easier to lose our perspective. In the end, though, the purpose of games is not just to distract and amuse ourselves, they help us to develop skills we need to succeed in life.

        When you say, “It is a fun game, but its not reality” I do have to stop and wonder about what you mean. Again, it sounds like you are saying that gender has no impact, no consequence in people’s lives, and that does not fit with what I have seen of the world. In a better, more ideal world, people would be recognized and valued for who they were regardless of what they appeared to be, but in this world we are typically valued more for what we are and treated as if that defines who we are. It is an assumption that leaves us with no choice about who we are. It’s a bit of a paradox; the bodies we are born with give us the gift of life, but limit our options in life before we can even know who we want to be. It is inconsiderate, at best, random and cruel at worst. I was blissfully happy to be alive until life began to strip away my hopes and dreams, everything I loved, telling me you cannot be this, you cannot have this, you cannot keep this, you do not deserve this, you have to make do with this instead. It’s all well and good to accept what is given to you, but if you can only have what is given to you, after everything you have is taken away, you begin to understand that nothing can be taken for granted. When you grow up with the world and everyone in it telling you that you’re not real, that “these things don’t matter” you have to wonder, “If that is true, then why does it hurt so much?”

      5. Perhaps it is because I never really wanted to do “social” things.

        I like company as much as the next person of course. But all my ambitions are things that don’t really involve society that much.

        I used to think I’d like to be a priest actually, and then I found out I couldn’t, but I didn’t want it that much, I moved on very quickly.

      6. I gave myself a couple of days to think about your reply, before responding. First, I should say thank you for commenting; I did not say that before, and I really do appreciate you saying something. The only way you can really tell if someone has read a page, and not just glanced at it and moved on to something else, is if they bother to say something. I appreciate that even if what they say is less than encouraging. Your responses, while brief and occasionally cryptic, have been challenging, so thank you! I am sorry you did not respond to the question I asked in my previous response, about whether you honestly wanted to understand why some people identify so strongly with gender. I mean, that was the main point of your second response, and it really got me thinking. That has already had a big effect on things I’ve posted since. Because those posts do kind of go off in a different direction, they don’t really address the question you’ve raised.

        I find it intriguing that you find gender identification so strange; that is, it makes me wonder if it is the gender aspect or the identification aspect that is so mystifying. Do you find it just as strange that people identify strongly with their nationality (native or adopted) or religion, or profession? I mean, if you really think about it, people identify with a lot of things, and tend to feel very strongly about it when they do. If the only part of identification that seems strange to you is gender identification, it might just be that you are gender neutral.

        In your last response, though, you said, “Perhaps it is because I never really wanted to do “social” things.” I might take that to mean that you tend to be introverted, which covers everything from being shy, aloof, alienated, isolated, sheltered, remote, insular, awkward, anti-social, self-involved, preoccupied, or any of long list of things without specifying which. You say you like the company of others, but mostly do your own thing, and that sounds pretty comfortable. On the other hand, while you’re saying you never wanted much from other people, you mentioned only one thing that you have been denied by other people. Even assuming you really wanted to understand someone in my position, I would have to know you and what you’ve been through in order to figure out how to explain it.

        In my life, the emphasis on gender began with people who objected to my natural character, forcing me to focus on figuring out what I would have to be in order to be accepted for who I am. In simple terms, I was judged based on the characteristic of my body, and there was more to me than that. You say you once wanted to be a priest, and I assume you meant that you were denied that opportunity because you were female. I suppose that gives you some insight, and if you’ve ever been forced to be something you are not, you would have a little more. You just have to increase the frequency of events like that, and the severity of the consequences for refusing or failing to conform, until it becomes inescapably oppressive, so that you lie awake every night struggling to figure out who you are. In the end, I identify as female in spite of being male because that part of my identity was under constant attack — is it surprising at all that it became the strongest part of me?

      7. I suppose it is not surprising. Although it is rather sad.

        Actually though, I thought of a way I can relate more.
        I absolutely feel like a child. I feel utterly perplexed by adult society, and yet people expect me to be an adult, to know how to act as an adult, to understand all their secret adult rules of behavior that are as mysterious to me as integral calculus. When I interact I want to be treated like the child I just know I am, but I am treated like an adult and it fills me with insecurity.

        Is it like that?

      8. You know what, that is exactly what it is like. I think that is one of the reasons I prefer to say I’m a girl; I never feel quite right saying I think of myself as a woman, as would be appropriate for my age, but I do not feel like I had a childhood. Most of the time, I feel like a kid trapped in nightmare, and all of the time I’ve spent trying to do what is expected of me, it all feels like a lie and I am just losing more of myself the longer I go along with it. No matter how “intelligent” or “reasonable” or “logical” I try to be, no matter how “practical” I am, I cannot really understand the adult mind, even though I’ve driven myself half crazy figuring out the rules they live by trying to avoid getting killed playing their game.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from eye of paradox - in the ashes of ideas hides the spark of understanding

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading